List of Victims of Murder, Manslaughter, and other Violent Ends

February 2, 2009 at 4:10 pm (victims) (, , , , )

Victims of Blair County in reverse chronological order (the latest are listed first.)  If you are aware of other victims, please post them here by using the comment feature.  Please include the victim’s name,  the  date, the location, and any other information.
More details on each crime can be found by clicking the link to the right, in alphabetical order.  Many of these cases are still being researched.

*Pages on a pending case will not be made viewable until after the resolution of the case.

Betsy Aurandt, of Frankstown Township, April 28, 2011
*John Joseph Purcell III, of Lancaster, April 10, 2009: (Manslaughter charge against Brandon Ott of Allegheny Township).
*Raymond E. Williams, in Altoona, April 6, 2009
*Scott Garlick of Hollidaysburg, in Altoona, April 6, 2009
*Margo Davis, Altoona, 2009
Tina Hoover, Altoona, 2008
Kathy Miller, Altoona, 2008 (manslaughter conviction)
Shawn Noel, age 18 years, of Altoona, PA April 2008
Marcus Chomry, near Claysburg, July of 2008
Tammie Reffner, Hollidaysburg, April 18, 2008
Shane William Sullivan, in Altoona, January 19, 2007
Beth Sprankle, of Altoona PA.  February 9, 2007
Dale Zunich of Altoona PA May 2006 (in Huntingdon County)
James Tucker, age 22, of Altoona PA April 2006 (in Cambria County(?))
Jared Klein, in Tyrone,  December 26 2005
Sandy Teeters of Tyrone,  November 19, 2005
Al Mignon of Altoona, PA.  Aug 2005
Freddy Rickabaugh of Altoona, PA Aug 2005
Steve Heiss of Altoona, PA Aug 2005
Dwayne Chamberlain, 2005
Starson Walker, 2004 (manslaughter charge against Carol J. Bright.  She was killed in a car accident in March 2006 before being brought to trial).
Tina Miller, in Hollidaysburg, June of 2004
Beverly Yohn, February of 2004
Sherri Dively, in Claysburg, PA September 23, 2002
Raymond Bracken of Altoona, PA March 19, 2002
Margorie Bracken of Altoona, PA March 19, 2002
Patience Ferguson, 2001
Sherrie Jackson, 2001
Randy Buchanan, in Altoona, June 21, 2001
Patricia Clapper, in Newry, August 2000
John Eichelberger, in Altoona, 2000
Arlene Piper, July 18, 1999
James Mowry, in Altoona, 1998
Julie Klock, in Altoona, April 29, 1997
Mary Ann Klock, in Altoona, April 29, 1997
Ashley Decker, in Altoona, March 27, 1997
David Wayne, November 11, 1996
Melody Curtis, of Florida, in Tyrone, June 29, 1996
Krista Ruggles, age 16 years, of Duncansville PA 1995 (in Ocean City, MD)
Shirley Becker, January 1995
Harold Matley, September of 1986
Ruth Ann Watson, in December of 1984
“Sweet Adelaide”, in Altoona, November 3, 1981
John Yorgy, Altoona, May of 1981
Alfred Walls, Altoona, April of 1981
Tina Marie Crone, Altoona, March of 1981
Elwood Figard, Altoona, December of 1980
Betty Jean Shade, of Altoona, 1979
Dennis Hileman, near Tipton, November 1979
Robert Dean Stout, in Altoona, March 1979
Gary Alan Phillips, Frankstown Township, August 15, 1978
Robin Hallman, in Juniata, Altoona, June 1, 1978
Gary Allan Phillips, 1978
Deborah Miller, April 19, 1978
Nicholas Grassmyer, near Tipton, September 10, 1977
Roseann Conrad, East Freedom, August 20, 1977
Gene Kaplan, Altoona, May 31, 1977
Harry Taylor, Altoona, October 24, 1976
Steven Crawford, Altoona, June 7, 1976
John Franell, Altoona, March 27, 1976
George Karns, near Duncansville, March 11, 1976
Elizabeth Shank, near Bellwood, March 4, 1976
Geraldine Gray, 1975
Barbara Rainelli, in Altoona, July 15, 1975
Robin Hallman, in Altoona, June 1, 1975
Dennis Deyarmin, in Altoona, May 26, 1975
Wilbur Packard, May 1975
Edward Shope, Jr, Altoona, April 23, 1975
Curtis Querry, in Altoona, April 8, 1974
David Bergstad, June 23, 1971 (Doubts about outcome)
Ida Carbone, in Altoona, June 3, 1971
Raymond Thomas, December 4, 1970
Charlotte Paquette, February 5, 1970
Pamela Galanick, Hollidaysburg, about October 31, 1968
Darrell Johnson, of Pittsburgh, in Duncansville, December 19, 1967
David Berkheimer, July 17, 1967
Betty Jane Sharpless, of Hollidaysburg, July 1, 1966
Susan Smith, in Claysburg, January 28, 1964 (Conclusion unknown)
Bonnie Blair, Altoona, May 15, 1963
William Taylor, 1962
Richard Lightner, near Williamsburg, May 20, 1961 (acquittal; self-defense)
James Lau of York, in Altoona, November 23, 1958 (acquittal)
Dugald Wilson, December 30, 1956
Frank Wyland, October 11, 1956
Samuel Leamer, in Frankstown Township, November 22, 1955
William Collins, in Altoona, February or March of 1954
Bertram Isenberg, November 21, 1953
Rose St. Clair, June 11, 1953
Verle K. Robinson, in Altoona, April 25, 1953
Annabelle Gutshall, 1952
Linda Gutshall, 1952
Kathryn Emma Kirstner, in Altoona, April 12, 1949
Thelma (Edwards) Rhodes, near Martinsburg, December 21, 1946
Cora Mae (Baker) Anderson, in Hollidaysburg, April 10, 1946
Frances Macedonia, in Altoona, July 10, 1943
Mary Musto, of Altoona, in Hollidaysburg, April of 1943
Thomas Benjamin, in Altoona, May 27, 1939
Thomas Fisher, in Altoona, December of 1937
Edgar K. Smith, in Altoona, 1936
Matthew Karmendi, in Altoona, April 22, 1936
Winifred Pierce OR Elmo Noakes, near Altoona, November 24, 1934
Catherine Forrest, in Altoona, August 23, 1934
Gloria Huntner, her 2 children, and 5 children of Melissa Dillion, in Hensheytown, April 13, 1932
John Zeilinger, in Tyrone, December 2, 1930
Paul Sichera, in Altoona, November 28, 1930
Lucian Change, in Altoona, October 29, 1930
Frank Gates, in East Freedom, October 10, 1930
Rosanna Logan, September 23, 1929
Edward O’Hara, in Claysburg, September 5, 1927
Joseph Joross, in Altoona, March 16, 1927
Angelo Dillaloga, in Bennington, October 12, 1924
Lizzie Albright, in Altoona, January 23, 1924
Archie Cleveland, in Altoona, August 16, 1923
Carmello Caffaretti, August 23, 1921
William Neihaus, August 3, 1921
John Rataczyk, in Altoona, January 10, 1920
Peter Martin, in Altoona, about 1918
Michael McGinley, October 13, 1915
David Mobley, January 1914
James Veign, January 1914
Mrs. Michael Briney, Altoona, 1909
Mary Stet, Altoona, 1907
Mrs Cirullo, December 27, 1906
Sarassin Timodo, at Cove Forge, May 23, 1906 (may not have been murder)
Silas Cooper, in Altoona, May 21, 1906
Tony Berandi, in Altoona, May 8, 1906
Mrs. William Holman, in Williamsburg, February 28, 1906
Ciro Daniel, near Williamsburg, 1904
Tucinnata Basilio, near Hollidaysburg, February 25, 1904
Herman Henderson, in Altoona, April 11, 1903
Eron Dunervish, on “New Portage work,” December 27, 1902 (may not be Blair County)
Thomas King, in Altoona, July 2, 1899
Frank Myers, in Altoona, June 4, 1899 (may have been accidental)
Two Unnamed infants, in Altoona, October 16, 1898
Frank McClelland, at Fostoria, May 12, 1898
Robert Barber, at Tunnelhill April 27, 1898
Robert Luther, August 21, 1897
Infant Martin, at Royer, December 15, 1896
John King, at Hollidaysburg, June 21, 1896
William McGregor, in Altoona, January 22, 1896
Michael Splaci, August 23, 1895
W.A. Stewart, July 9, 1895
Henry Bonnecka, in Altoona, April 7, 1895
Joseph Bender, 1894
William Butler, in Martinsburg, April 9, 1894
Emma Ingold, February 22, 1893
Jane Lewis, 1890
Hugh Stewart, October 13, 1890
Frank Mender
Laura Emeigh, 1888
Harrison Shope, July 5, 1888
Unknown Female Child, April 28, 1888
Agnes Husfield, November 1, 1886
Linder Lewis, April 1, 1886
? Ulrich, in Altoona, August 30, 1884
Mary Knott Beach, in Altoona, April of 1884
? Swanger, in Altoona, 1881
Infant Gardner, 1881
Female Noel, July 31, 1881
Male Parker Child, in Altoona, August 12, 1871
Infant, perhaps Unnamed Robeson, in Altoona, January 10, 1861
? Osborne, in Fostoria, August 22, 1860
Infants, in Altoona, April 5, 1860
D. Bernier, in Altoona, October 20, 1858
Samuel Norcross, in Altoona, January 16, 1857
Unknown male Riddle, July 27, 1856 (no charges filed)
David Hewit, in Hollidaysburg, July 12, 1856 (manslaughter)
Benjamin Davis, in Williamsburg, June 14 1856
James Johnston, in Hollidaysburg, June 8, 1856
Unknown Victim(s) of the Portage Railroad Riots, may not have been in Blair County, May 16, 1853
Mary Ann McCoy Shirley, near Newry, November 19, 1852
Unborn Shirley baby, near Newry, November 19, 1852
Nathaniel Edmundson, in Hollidaysburg, September 17, 1850

The little world of Blair County has seen more than its share of murders, some of them cruel and savage beyond description. This site is an effort to memorialize those victims, those people who never would have wanted to be within the pages of a book like this, and yet, it happened to them. They were not so very different from you or I. Most were good people. They were mothers and wives; fathers and husbands; children and older people. They have been black, and white, rich and poor. Most were life-long residents in Blair County, with family ties to the community. Some were just passing through on a train. Whatever their stories, they all had one thing in common: None of them deserved to die, when they did, and how they did.  This site endeavors to remember the Blair County victims of this most violent of crimes; it is hoped that nothing contained therein would be deemed inappropriate or offense by family members, friends, or acquaintances of anyone mentioned on this site.  We apologize in advance for any errors of fact and will speedily correct them when brought to our attention.

Permalink 7 Comments

Proposed Cover

April 23, 2010 at 11:33 am (Uncategorized)

Proposed cover

Permalink Leave a Comment

A note on the current status of inmates:

July 19, 2009 at 12:08 pm (murder)

On the current status of convicted offenders:  All information comes directly from, and only from, the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections website.  The Department’s website complies with Pennsylvania Criminal History Record Information Act (CHRIA), 18 Pa. C.S.A. Section 9101 et seq. CHRIA limits the type of criminal justice information that may be disseminated to the public.

Permalink Leave a Comment

Memorials

June 8, 2009 at 1:30 pm (murder) ()

On June 16, 2009, Michael McGinley was honored at the Blair County Courthouse.  His name was added to the slain officer’s memorial there.  Also in the courthouse yard is a stone monument to the victims of murder in Blair County.  The District Attorney’s office has put a memorial within the courthouse listing victims by name, and is working on a scrapbook project with the families of victims.

Permalink Leave a Comment

Definitions

February 14, 2009 at 12:55 pm (murder)

In the days of the early republic, there were numerous crimes punishable by death, and because the sentence was mandatory, it was difficult to get a jury to convict these criminals.  Pennsylvania Attorney General William Bradford guided reforms.  Pennsylvania became the first state to break down murder in degrees.  An Act of the legislation of Pennsylvania (22d April 1794) declares all murder which shall be perpetrated by means of poison or by lying in wait or by any other kind of willful, deliberate, and premeditated killing, or which shall be committed in the perpetration of or attempt to perpetrate any arson, rape, robbery, or burglary shall be deemed murder of the first degree ; and all other kinds of murder shall be deemed murder of the second degree. The statute, says Bishop (Commentaries on the Criminal Law, vol. ii. § 745), “is the parent of all the others.”

In 1834, Pennsylvania became the first state to ban public executions.  Counties, including Blair County, conducted their own executions by hanging, inside the walls of the county jail.  In 1913, Pennsylvania began using the electric chair at Rockview State Prison in Centre County for all executions, and the task became the duty of the state.  From 1915 to 1962, 348 men and 2 women were put to death there. The law required six witnesses to be present and testify to the death; in addition, no more than six members of the media were also permitted.  An electrician was hired to pull the actual switch, gradually sending 12 amperes and 2000 volts through the condemned.

In 1990, Governor Casey changed the method of execution to lethal injection, but it was not used until 1995.

Pennsylvania’s current definitions are thus:

§ 2501. Criminal homicide.
(a) Offense defined.-A person is guilty of criminal homicide if he intentionally, knowingly, recklessly or negligently causes the death of another human being.
(b) Classification.-Criminal homicide shall be classified as murder, voluntary manslaughter, or involuntary manslaughter.

§ 2502. Murder.
(a) Murder of the first degree.-A criminal homicide constitutes murder of the first degree when it is committed by an intentional killing.
(b) Murder of the second degree.-A criminal homicide constitutes murder of the second degree when it is committed while defendant was engaged as a principal or
an accomplice in the perpetration of a felony.
(c) Murder of the third degree.-All other kinds of murder shall be murder of the third degree. Murder of the third degree is a felony of the first degree.
(d) Definitions.-As used in this section the following words and phrases shall have the meanings given to them in this subsection:
. . . .
“Intentional killing.”
Killing by means of poison, or by lying in wait, or by any other kind of willful, deliberate and premeditated killing.
“Perpetration of a felony.”
The act of the defendant in engaging in or being an accomplice in the commission of, or an attempt to commit, or flight after committing, or attempting to
commit robbery, rape, or deviate sexual intercourse by force or threat of force, arson, burglary or kidnapping.
“Principal.”
A person who is the actor or perpetrator of the crime.

The death penalty is applied in Pennsylvania in cases where a defendant is found guilty of first degree murder. A separate hearing is held for the consideration of aggravating and mitigating circumstances. If at least one of the ten aggravating circumstances listed in the law and none of the eight mitigating factors are found to be present, the verdict must be death.

Any post-trial motions are usually then heard and considered, and then the convicted person is formally sentenced. An automatic review of the case by the state Supreme Court follows. The court can either uphold the sentence or vacate it and impose life sentence.

If the Supreme Court affirms the sentence, the case goes to the Governor’s Office where it is reviewed by appropriate legal counsel and, ultimately, by the Governor himself. Only the Governor may set the execution date, which is done through the signing of a document known as the Governor’s Warrant. By law, all executions are carried out at the State Correctional Institution at Rockview.

Permalink 7 Comments

Next page »

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.